By: Ciopages Staff Writer
Updated on: Aug 13, 2022
Is it possible to assemble an ERP platform with best of breed applications? It depends! A number of terms are being thrown around these days in the enterprise resource planning (ERP) world, one of them being “best of breed.” This moniker refers to the identification of a software package for a specific function being the agreed-upon best choice available for that task. Unfortunately, what has also been a challenge with best of breed choices involves integration, trying to get the different tools to talk to each other. Prior to ERP options, this essentially involved no talk but translation instead, with the information exported from one tool in an output form, and then re-inputted into another manually. Eventually, this morphed into middle step software programs to allow bridging, better known as enterprise integration technology (EIT), but clearly best of breed was not yet functioning as a true ERP in the literal sense of the name. That was only a few years ago, however. And now the best of breed alternative is extremely viable in its own right.
Small to medium companies, under cost pressures to stretch their resources, have been the big demand player for economical ERP choices and designs, which best of breed ERP packaging has become quite attractive to. Niche ERP consultants have found their place providing guidance in implementation as well, adding to the dynamic.
ERP in any form offers big benefits for the long-term, particularly in data management and leveraging. And best of breed packages can provide the means to cobbling together custom-sized systems that handle the nuances of a given company versus only providing a large corporation standard one has to fit business processes to. However, integration is still a key conduit to making things work. Advantages for this approach include:
However, a company still needs to take into account the limitations of best of breed packaging. These can include:
If committed to using the best of breed approach for an ERP design, a company should first put a good effort in planning needs and wants first. There are plenty of tools, but they’re not as important as the company figuring out its particular advantage first. What makes the company unique and above everyone else in its market? That competitive advantage needs to be completely identified. Once done, then the appropriate tools and their vendors can be identified that help make that advantage happen faster and better. The more common needs such as accounting or personnel management are far easier to address by a large selection of tools available.
The weak point in the design is the interfacing. Because it can foul up the most promising of choices, interfacing has to be confirmed at each step of adding modules. Even with best of breed, the applications are only so good as the ability to talk to each other correctly. As a result, each tool added needs to be confirmed that it can interface properly with the others. If not, it should not be used, no matter how good it may be in a particular function.
A company will need the help of an integration specialist or software to work through these interface tests and installation. They frequently require custom coding and bridge patching to make things work correctly, and that work needs to follow a standardized approach to ensure it can be maintained and updated as necessary down the road. Again, one does not have this added aspect with a suite approach, but the flip side is even with the added customization the best of breed ERP cost can still be considerably less.
Keep in mind that various security protocols may also be necessary. Because a best of breed approach does not share one software base platform, security aspects have to match the tool used in a given functional area. So it can be quite possible that an ERP system has four or five different security protocols to protect the different modules included.
Design doesn’t end with running software. Training will also be a greater challenge. Because best of breed tools use different software, each one has to be learned by given employees. Unlike a suite which uses the same interface across every function, best of breed can be quite disparate in nature. That means multiple training challenges versus one suite ERP training.
There’s a lot of chatter about how the latest app is solving problems exponentially. And that constant messaging has a huge influence on steering companies away from the idea of suite, one-manufacturer ERP and instead go to best of breed built ERP. That said, best of breed ERP building isn’t a perfect panacea. It comes with its own challenges and, as mentioned before, a company could still find itself eventually needing to acquire a suite ERP anyways. Ideally, an ERP should make working between offices far easier, leveraging everyone’s data to produce even better business processes and results. However, best of breed has the potential to also add silos to an ERP project and move a company further away from the digital ideal instead of closer.
Have you had any experience or heard of folks successfully assembling an ERP solution with best of breed applications?
Individual License: Where we offer an individual license, you can use the deliverable for personal use. You pay only once for using the deliverable forever. You are entitled any new updates within 12 months.
Enterprise License: If you are representing a company, irrespective of size, and intend to use the deliverables as a part of your enterprise transformation, the enterprise license is applicable in your situation. You pay only once for using the deliverable forever. You are entitled any new updates within 12 months.
Consultancy License: A consulting or professional services or IT services company that intends to use the deliverables for their client work need to pay the consultancy license fee. You pay only once for using the deliverable forever. You are entitled any new updates within 12 months.
We are sorry, but we cannot send or show sample deliverables. There are two reasons: A) The deliverables are our intellectual property, and we cannot share the same. B) While you may be a genuine buyer, our experience in the past has not been great with too many browsers and not many buyers. We believe the depth of the information in the product description and the snippets we provide are sufficient to understand the scope and quality of our products.
We process each transaction manually and hence, processing a deliverable may take anywhere from a few minutes to up to a day. The reason is to ensure appropriate licensing and also validating the deliverables.
Your best bet is to log in to the portal and download the products from the included links. The links do not expire.
Yes. You can only download the products three times. We believe that is sufficient for any genuine usage situation. Of course, once you download, you can save electronic copies to your computer or a cloud drive.
You can share the deliverables within a company for proper use. You cannot share the deliverables outside your company. Selling or giving away free is prohibited, as well.
Not generally. Compared to our professional services fee, the price of our products is a fraction of what we charge for custom work. Hence, our business model does not support pre-sales support.
Yes, for a separate fee. You can hire our consultants for remote help and in some cases for onsite assistance. Please Contact Us.